0
Anonymous Posted 14 years ago
Grammar

does this sentence make sense?

does the sentence: my classmate, she sings in lessons, make sense?
  

Top answer

No. "Sings in lessons" is not clear. Do you mean to say: My classmate [she] sings during lessons.

  • No.
  • "Sings in lessons" is not clear.
  • Do you mean to say: My classmate [she] sings during lessons.
  • Or to say: My classmate [she] is taking singing lessons.
  • Or: My classmate [she] sings her lessons.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
No. "Sings in lessons" is not clear.
Do you mean to say:
My classmate [she] sings during lessons.
Or to say:
My classmate [she] is taking singing lessons.
Or:
My classmate [she] sings her lessons.

Do you see the problem?
0
Anonymousmy classmate, she sings in lessons
For one thing, you can't have both of those underlined sections in one sentence. You've got to have either My classmate sings or She sings; you can't have both. The meaning of the rest is unclear.

CJ

Related Questions