0
NL888 Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

Does "the combination" refer to "collective self-emancipators"?

Context:
Kal Ashraf wrote:

Perhaps in rejecting the critical dualism–Lincoln as individual emancipator pitted against collective self-emancipators–there is an opportunity to recognise the greater persuasiveness of the combination. In a sense, yes: a racist, flawed Lincoln did something heroic, and not in lieu of collective participation, but next to, and enabled, by it. To venerate a singular ‘Great Emancipator’ may be as reductive as dismissing the significance of Lincoln’s actions. Who he was as a man, no one of us can ever really know. So it is that the version of Lincoln we keep is also the version we make.[79]
MOre:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emancipation_Proclamation#Critiques
  

Top answer

NL888 Does "the combination" refer to "collective self-emancipators"? No. It refers to "individual emancipator [and] collective self-emancipators".

  • NL888 Does "the combination" refer to "collective self-emancipators"?
  • No.
  • It refers to "individual emancipator [and] collective self-emancipators".
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
NL888Does "the combination" refer to "collective self-emancipators"?
No. It refers to "individual emancipator [and] collective self-emancipators".
0
Hi Emotion: hi.
What dose "collective self-emancipators" mean?
0
MIGWhat dose "collective self-emancipators" mean?
I'll let NL 888 answer that—he's the one who's reading the book.
0
Is this correct?
"A collective aim and participation for emancipation"
0
MIGIs this correct?"A collective aim and participation for emancipation"
What is it supposed to mean?
0
First, what dose "self-emancipator" mean?
Its not only about slavery, I think it has a more general meaning.
is it right?
Whoever fights for equal rights or for example help ill or poor people to live in better condition we call him/her "self-emancipator".
0
Ok, I don't get it.
Nobody knows?
0
Well, I got the episode from wiki, not the book. I guess that it may have referred to that the emancipation of American blacks is the result of collective actions, not of Lincoln's action alone.
Am I on the right track?

Related Questions