0
Jackson6612 Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Does every language have a grammar?

Once someone told me that every language should have a grammar in order to be functional. Is it true? Many tribes living in Africa don't have any written form of their languages. Do such languages have a grammar?
  

Top answer

Hi, I would think so. I suppose it depends on how you define 'language' and 'grammar'. Clive

  • Hi, I would think so.
  • I suppose it depends on how you define 'language' and 'grammar'.
  • Clive
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
Hi,
I would think so.
I suppose it depends on how you define 'language' and 'grammar'.
Clive
0
I think yes - every language shall give the owner a tool to different past and future time , as example. May be this language never be studied and described bu lingvist ?
0
Of course. Keep in mind that language existed long before writing. All languages have-require-rules for word order, sentence construction. etc. Further, all written grammar texts are attempts to describe (not specify) an already existing language.
0
ISU_152every language shall give the owner a tool to different past and future time
There are many languages that don't have a past or a future time and others that rely solely on context to express them.
0
Jackson6612Once someone told me that every language should have a grammar in order to be functional. Is it true? Many tribes living in Africa don't have any written form of their languages. Do such languages have a grammar?
Yes, all languages have a grammar. A grammar is simply a system by which the language works to connect sound with meaning. Having a wri
0
CalifJimyou only have meaningless random grunts, groans, twitters, and howlings!
That's how I feel when I listen to some of the "music" on the air these days!
0
Hee, hee. We must draft protest letters at once! Emotion: big smile

Jim
0
Jackson6612Many tribes living in Africa don't have any written form of their languages. Do such languages have a grammar?
Sure, as has already been said, grammar is not a constructive, but a descriptive thing, which means it is only a reflection of the properties of the language. Therefore, if there's a language, a grammar (or even several grammars) may be cre

Related Questions