Do these sentences mean the same thing?
I know that one of these sentences using the continuous tense, but in situations like this, is the meaning actually different?
"She had lived here for 10 years when I met her"
vs.
"She had been living here for 10 years when I met her"
If not, in which circumstances could they be different?
Top answer
anonymous in which circumstances could they be different? You might use the continuous form to show the idea of something impermanent, for example, if she was living somewhere unsuitable because she was so poor: She had been living [in the woods / on the streets / in a motel] for 10 years when I met her, but she hoped that some day she would have a home of her own. Other than that, the two sentences say the same thing.
- anonymous in which circumstances could they be different?
- You might use the continuous form to show the idea of something impermanent, for example, if she was living somewhere unsuitable because she was so poor: She had been living [in the woods / on the streets / in a motel] for 10 years when I met her, but she hoped that some day she would have a home of her own.
- Other than that, the two sentences say the same thing.
- CJ
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
anonymousin which circumstances could they be different?
You might use the continuous form to show the idea of something impermanent, for example, if she was living somewhere unsuitable because she was so poor: She had been living [in the woods / on the streets / in a motel] for 10 years when I met her, but she hoped that some day she would have a home
0
Related Questions