0
Fire1 Posted 6 years ago
Grammar

Do I have to insert a comma in this case?

" This is a unique situation for me being a first year student at IWU "

Do I have to insert a comma between "me" and "being" to make the sentence grammatical because it's not possible that two "me"s exist ? as in " This is a unique situation for me, being a first year student at IWU "

  

Top answer

fire1 " This is a unique situation for me being a first year student at IWU " Do I have to insert a comma between "me" and "being" to make the sentence grammatical because it's not possible that two "me"s exist ? as in " This is a unique situation for me, being a first year student at IWU " The structure is faulty, and the meaning is ambiguous. A comma won't help.

  • fire1 " This is a unique situation for me being a first year student at IWU " Do I have to insert a comma between "me" and "being" to make the sentence grammatical because it's not possible that two "me"s exist ?
  • as in " This is a unique situation for me, being a first year student at IWU " The structure is faulty, and the meaning is ambiguous.
  • A comma won't help.
  • I can't tell whether it means that the unique situation is his being a freshman or the unique situation is made unique by virtue of his being a freshman.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
fire1

" This is a unique situation for me being a first year student at IWU "

Do I have to insert a comma between "me" and "being" to make the sentence grammatical because it's not possible that two "me"s exist ? as in " This is a unique situation for me, being a first year student at IWU "

0
fire1This is a unique situation for me, being a first year student at IWU.

A comma (and a period) definitely helps, but it doesn't solve all the problems.

You can read it with the initial "This" as something outside the sentence or as "being a first-year student at IWU".

CJ

Related Questions