0
Ye Thu Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

Direct Speech to Indirect Speech

The bus conductor explained," This seat is set aside for monks".
If I rewrite this sentence as " The bus conductor explained that that seat was set aside for monks", is it grammatical? And can I leave out the conjuction "that"?
Thank you so much.
  

Top answer

Ye Thu is it grammatical? Yes. Ye Thu And can I leave out the conjuction "that"?

  • Ye Thu is it grammatical?
  • Yes.
  • Ye Thu And can I leave out the conjuction "that"?
  • I am not personally a big fan of leaving out "that" after "explained", but people do do so.
  • In your case it may be particularly awkward to read as the demonstrative "that" may at first glance appear to be a conjunction.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
Ye Thuis it grammatical?
Yes.
Ye Thu And can I leave out the conjuction "that"?
I am not personally a big fan of leaving out "that" after "explained", but people do do so. In your case it may be particularly awkward to read as the demonstrative "that" may at first glance appear to be a conjunction.

You s
0
Ye ThuThe bus conductor explained that that seat was set aside for monks.
Correct.
Ye ThuAnd can I leave out the conjunction "that"?
I don't recommend it because of two "that"s in a row.

CJ
0
Will I need to change "This" to "the" in the reported speech? Will it be grammatical? Thank you again.
0
e.g. The bus conductor explained that the seat is set aside for the monks.
0
Dear CJ, please check up my question and reply me. Thanks a million.
0
Ye ThuWill I need to change "This" to "the" in the reported speech? Will it be grammatical?
Yes, it is grammatical of course. If the demonstrative force of "this" in the original speech is important, then you should use "this" or "that" in the reported speech ("that" if the seat is now distant; "this" if it is still near). If the demonstrative force is not ver
0
Ye ThuDear CJ, please check up my question and reply me. Thanks a million.
See GPY's excellent answer.

Note that we are probably at opposite sides of the globe, so I may be sleeping while you are awake. There is no need to post a reminder for me to answer. After I have had my sleep I will get to your question.

Related Questions