0
Usenet Posted 22 years ago
Usage

Dilemna

Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.
  

Top answer

[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? [/nq] I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.

  • [nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)?
  • [/nq] I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

11 Answers
0
[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.
0
[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
Keeping the 'm' and 'n' separately articulated is about as hard as saying, 'inportant'.

Opening her own letter Dorothea saw that it was a lively continuation of his remonstrance with her fanatical sympathy and her wan
0
[nq:2]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
[nq:1]I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.[/nq]
I'd say it's just a spelling error. "Dilemna" doesn't show up at onelook.com. Google has a Richoux ratio for dilemma/dilemna of almost 100/1. And at lea
0
[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
1. Dilemna is an error, not a variant spelling, asevidenced by dictionaries.

2. Factual sources (e.g. dictionaries) are not ipsofacto infallible but remain a better source than
subjective intuitions or theories of
0
[nq:2]I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.[/nq]
[nq:1]I'd say it's just a spelling error. "Dilemna" doesn't show up at onelook.com. Google has a Richoux ratio for dilemma/dilemna ... about the misspelling. I don't know why the OP found "dilemna" "more natural." Jane Austen didn't name her novel "Emna."[/nq]
Although I'm looking forward to the forthcoming production of
0
[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
OED has only one usage of the word, in a cite for definition 1b of 'horned':
"b. Logic. horned syllogism (argument, etc.): the dilemma.
1548 Horned question (see horn n. 27). 1551 T. Wilson Logike (1580)34b, Dilemna, o
0
[nq:2]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
[nq:1]I must admit I've never seen the word dilemna before this.[/nq]
Nor I.
The English word is from Greek 'lemma'. There is a Greek word 'lemna' but it's irrelevant here - it means some kind of plant. Many Greek word
0
[nq:2]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vsdilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
[nq:1]OED has only one usage of the word, in a cite for definition 1b of 'horned': "b. Logic. horned syllogism ... dilemma is a double lemma and lemma is never properly spelt lemna except when it's duckweed. John Dean Oxford[/n
0
[nq:2]OED has only one usage of the word, in a ... spelt lemna except when it's duckweed. John Dean Oxford[/nq]
[nq:1]More natural because though all the dictionaries I could find spellit "dilemma", the majority of people I know spell it ... old. It isn't an ordinary error as it hasapparently been spread through the printed word. (Why else the illogical spelling?)[/nq]
I'm surprised you've
0
[nq:1]Does anyone know the history of the spelling "dilemna" (vs dilemma)? The first seems more natural but is apparently considered incorrect despite its wide use.[/nq]
http://www.onelook.com/ says there's no such word.
Milner and miller meant the same at one time. Might be a clue.

Milner is Yiddish for miller a

Related Questions