0
Jackson6612 Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

Didn't I tell you, John, that you were the best person I had ever seen?

Didn't I tell you, John, that you were the best person I had ever seen?

Does the above sentence mean that John isn't the best person anymore?
  

Top answer

No - it looks more as though John doesn't believe it and the person is emphasising his/her statement. Starting in this way is often a sign of exasperation: Mother to naughty child : Didn't I tell you not to climb onto the table? Now look what you've done - you have broken my bowl.

  • No - it looks more as though John doesn't believe it and the person is emphasising his/her statement.
  • Starting in this way is often a sign of exasperation: Mother to naughty child : Didn't I tell you not to climb onto the table?
  • Now look what you've done - you have broken my bowl.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
No - it looks more as though John doesn't believe it and the person is emphasising his/her statement.

Starting in this way is often a sign of exasperation:

Mother to naughty child : Didn't I tell you not to climb onto the table? Now look what you've done - you have broken my bowl.
0
Hi Jackson

Not at all. English is an inexact language and the use of the tenses is often determined by a phenomenon called the sequence of tenses, which results in sentences like your example or this one:

I knew he lived in Berlin.

The person may still live in Berlin but as knew is a past tense, lived is as well.

CB

Related Questions