0
Magic79 Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

"Did you shop" vs. "Did you go shopping"

Did you shop last night? (purposful shopping for (a) specific item(s)
vs.
Did you go shopping last night? (recreational activity)

Is there a real differnece between (shop verb) and (go shopping phrasal verb)?
  

Top answer

They recall me almost same things Magic79 but by saying "did you shop", I expect the other person to say something, at least to count the things he/she bought whereas by "go shopping" the first speaker, I, am not sure if she/he shopped or not. Witht he first question I seem to sound more confident. Of course these are what I understand.

  • They recall me almost same things Magic79 but by saying "did you shop", I expect the other person to say something, at least to count the things he/she bought whereas by "go shopping" the first speaker, I, am not sure if she/he shopped or not.
  • Witht he first question I seem to sound more confident.
  • Of course these are what I understand.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
They recall me almost same things Magic79 but by saying "did you shop", I expect the other person to say something, at least to count the things he/she bought whereas by "go shopping" the first speaker, I, am not sure if she/he shopped or not. Witht he first question I seem to sound more confident.

Of course these are what I understand.
0
Good then Doll, what if the two questions were turned into statements. Would the meaning you implied continue to hold true?

I shopped last night. (I bought a few things)
vs.
I went shopping last night. (I am just saying I went to the mall but I have not given any statement as to whether I bought something or not)
???????
0
DollI expect the other person to say something, at least to count the things he/she bought
"To shop" doesn't require a purchase. It doesn't even require a visit to shops, only intent.
0
I agree Huevos but you know women always have expectations.

Magic79, you summarized what I understand.
0
Shop - is a funny word. Depeding on context, it has varying meanings:

I went car shopping last weekend. = It merely means you went to different dealships to compare models
and prices. Without further context, the mood to the listeners is that I didn't buy a car.

There is no more food in the fridge. I need to do some grocery shoppping after work. Expectation:
I need to res
0
Thanks Goodman, Doll, and Huevos for lending us your subtle understanding of the English language.
0
Which shops did you go to?

Related Questions