0
Navitasan Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

Did you know anyone who...

1) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who died in a car accident?


Can't that sentence mean two things:

1a) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who had died in a car accident?

1b) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who would die in a car accident?


Gratefully,

Navi

  

Top answer

navitasan Can't that sentence mean two things: Well, technically, yes, but I had to put my thinking cap on to get your second interpretation. navitasan 1a) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who had died in a car accident? This is a verb-tense snakepit when you start analyzing it.

  • navitasan Can't that sentence mean two things: Well, technically, yes, but I had to put my thinking cap on to get your second interpretation.
  • navitasan 1a) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who had died in a car accident?
  • This is a verb-tense snakepit when you start analyzing it.
  • When you look at it, you can't know a dead person, so you would have had to have known them.
  • See what I mean?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
navitasanCan't that sentence mean two things:

Well, technically, yes, but I had to put my thinking cap on to get your second interpretation.

navitasan1a) When you started work at our office, did you know anyone who had died in a car accident?

This is a verb-tense snakepit when you start analyzing it. When you look

Related Questions