0
Taka Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Development

Maybe I asked this question before, but let me ask nonetheless. About this:

The intellectual transformation associated with the Scientific Revolution led to a new confidence in the value of the investigation of nature and its control, a development which is fundamental to an understanding of the importance of science in modern society.

About 'a development', is it a restatement of the sentence in front 'X led to Y'? Or is it something else?
  

Top answer

The development could refer grammatically to either 'transformation' or 'confidence', or to the whole 'transformation led to confidence', but I think it refers to 'confidence' in the writer's mind.

  • The development could refer grammatically to either 'transformation' or 'confidence', or to the whole 'transformation led to confidence', but I think it refers to 'confidence' in the writer's mind.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
The development could refer grammatically to either 'transformation' or 'confidence', or to the whole 'transformation led to confidence', but I think it refers to 'confidence' in the writer's mind.
0
Is 'a new confidence' itself really a development which is fundamental to an understanding of the importance of science in modern society?

Isn't the process, or the history, in which the intellectual transformation associated with the Scientific Revolution led to a new confidence in the value of the investigation of nature and its control,
0
I have given you my opinion.
0
I wonder if you could present a sound reason for your opinion.
0
I already have. Oh, maybe I haven't. It is because 'confidence' seems intellectually to me to be the development the author speaks of.
0
Even though the rest of the text actually describes the significant historical fact as this, would you still believe so?

The cultural values associated with the pursuit of natural knowledge were a significant characteristic of seventeenth-century society. Science expressed the values of technological progress, intellectual understanding and the celeb
0
Now I see why you see 'confidence' as the referent; sometimes 'a development' can refer not only to the process but to the end result. I understand that.

But I believe 'X led to Y' is explicitly a 'a development' while the end result is implicitly so. Plus, the entire text seems to be about the cultural values associa

Related Questions