0
Vsuresh Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Dangling modifier

Please help me with the dangling modifier.


Question: For sale: Mixing bowl set designed to please a cook with a round bottom for efficient beating.

Answer: For sale: Mixing bowl set with a round bottom for efficient beating designed to please a cook.

Can we accept this as well?

Mixing bowl set designed with a round bottom for efficient beating to please a cook.

  

Top answer

Obviously the first version suggests something quite inappropriate and funny - the second makes the statement clearly and stops us picturing a cook with a round bottom etc. In your alternative version we also do not have to clear up any confusion over the cook's bottom, so I suggest that it makes a perfectly acceptable alternative. It retains the meaning and explains why the cook will be pleased, even if the emphasis has changed very slightly.

  • Obviously the first version suggests something quite inappropriate and funny - the second makes the statement clearly and stops us picturing a cook with a round bottom etc.
  • In your alternative version we also do not have to clear up any confusion over the cook's bottom, so I suggest that it makes a perfectly acceptable alternative.
  • It retains the meaning and explains why the cook will be pleased, even if the emphasis has changed very slightly.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

Obviously the first version suggests something quite inappropriate and funny - the second makes the statement clearly and stops us picturing a cook with a round bottom etc.

In your alternative version we also do not have to clear up any confusion over the cook's bottom, so I suggest that it makes a perfectly acceptable alternative. It retains the meaning and explains why the cook will b

Related Questions