0
Fab54 Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

Couldn't do it / wouldn't be able to do it

Hi,
To express the idea of "not beeing able to do something" can we say "couldn't do it"...I give you an example:

(situation: people are at a party)
- Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow!
- After this party I wouldn't be able to get up so early!!

Can we replace the second sentence (without changing the meaning) by:
-After this party I couldn't get up so early!! (I'd say that this sentence has not the same meaning, but Im not sure...)

Thanks for your help
  

Top answer

I WILL give you an example: (situation: people are at a party) - Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow! - After this party I wouldn't be able to get up so early!! Can we replace the second sentence (without changing the meaning) by: -After this party I couldn't get up so early!!

  • I WILL give you an example: (situation: people are at a party) - Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow!
  • - After this party I wouldn't be able to get up so early!!
  • Can we replace the second sentence (without changing the meaning) by: -After this party I couldn't get up so early!!
  • ) JT: Actually, since Richard is presently at the party and he is speaking about an event, "getting up", that has yet to occur, neither sentence can be used.
  • Instead, Richard could say, After this party I WON'T be able to get up that early!!
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
To express the idea of "not being able to do something" can we say "couldn't do it"...I WILL give you an example:

(situation: people are at a party)
- Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow!
- After this party I wouldn't be able to get up so early!!

Can we replace the second sentence (without changing the meaning) by:
-After this party I couldn't get up so e
0
Thanks for your answer!
In fact I wanted to express a conditional meaning: the second person that speaks is not Richard.
The idea was:
- Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow!
- (John says) (If I were Richard) after this party I couldn't get up so early!!

In that context, the second sentence is correct?

Thanks
0
In fact I wanted to express a conditional meaning: the second person that speaks is not Richard.
The idea was:
- Richard has to get up at 5am tomorrow!
- (John says) (If I were Richard) after this party I couldn't get up so early!!

In that context, the second sentence is correct?

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

Wha
0
Thanks for your help!!
0
Hi Just The Truth,

you just have to add / to your attempts to quote and it will work:

............

(remove the spaces too)
0
Hi Just The Truth,

you just have to add / to your attempts to quote and it will work:

............

(remove the spaces too)


Yup, it worked. Thanks, Elena.
0
Here you neeed to consider following impotant point.
At what time you are expressing this, mean you have to clearly state, whether it is for future or past.
1:sentence is ok if during the party, (John says) "after this party I wouldn't be able get up so early!! (sentence nature is future)
2:sentence is ok if the next day of the party, (John says) "after that party I couldn't get up s

Related Questions