I am trying to figure out a few things about these three could/could have/to be able to as I don't understand some things. In the grammar book by M. Swan it is written that:
1 Could (in the past) - conveys a general ability to do something within a long period of time When I was young I could ride a horse. Able to - means that something was done in a certain situation I was able to ride a horse yesterday.
So, according to M. Swan it's not right to say: I could ride a horse yesterday.
But I hear native speakers say things like
I could do it yesterday. I could start the engine yesterday but I can't do it today.
Is it a mistake to say that provided we comply with Swan's rules or does it mean something else? Shouldn't it be:
I was able to do it yesterday. I was able to start the engine yesterday but I can't do it today. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 2 Some people say that "I could do it yesterday" - means possibility but not the ability.
So "I could do it yesterday" means: "I had an opportunity to do it yesterday." Well, in this case I wonder what is the difference between: I could do it yesterday I could have done it yesterday. --------------------------------------------------------------------- 3 Native speakers say that: I could do it yesterday, but I didn't want to. - is wrong. It should be I could have done it yesterday, but I didn't want to. Then I don't understand why I could start the engine yesterday. - is correct It should also be I could have started the engine yesterday.
Top answer
'could' is not used for past probability.
— MSoni
'could' is not used for past probability.
Free · every Monday
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.