0
Mr. Tom Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Could you explain as to where you have been all this while?

Hi

Is this sentence natural?

Could you explain as to where you have been all this while?

Thanks,

Tom
  

Top answer

Mr. Tom Could you explain as to where you have been all this while? No.

  • Mr.
  • Tom Could you explain as to where you have been all this while?
  • No.
  • It's not natural.
  • It's wrong.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
Mr. TomCould you explain as to where you have been all this while?
No. It's not natural. It's wrong. You can fix it like this:

Could you explain where you have been all this while?

Or like this:

Could you [give / offer] an explanation as to where you have been all this while?

CJ
0
Thanks, CJ.

Does it mean that "noun + as to" works in most situation but "verb + as to" doesn't?

Do these work?

He asked several questions as to our repeated failure over that small issue.
He questioned why we had failed repeatedly over that small issue.

Tom
0
Mr. TomHe asked several questions as to our repeated failure over that small issue.
This one is borderline. It's understandable, but not quite right because we'd say "about" instead of "as to" in this case.
Mr. TomHe questioned why we had failed repeatedly over that small issue.
Good.
Mr. Tom"noun +
0
Examples of "as to" (regarding; about). Do not confuse with "so as to", "so ... as to", or "such ... as to".

Probably most uses of "as to" are followed by an indirect question, i.e., a clause that starts with a question word (whether, why, how, how much, what, which, when, where).

Debate is raging as to whether ... or ....
There is some doubt as to whether the informa

Related Questions