0
Kenta Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Could you check my English?

Hello. I made two dialogues. Could you chech them?

No. 1

M: I planted 10 tulip bulbs in my garden this spring,
but some of them didn't come up.

F: Well, but they are beautiful, anyway.

M: Thank you. I hope we will be able to enjoy more tulips next spring.

No. 2

M: We're going to have some friends over for a party next Saturday
and I hope you'll join us, too.

F: I'd love to. I have nothing scheduled in particular this weekend.
[for the weekend]

M: Great. Anytime after one will be fine with us.

Thank you!
  

Top answer

Kenta, you plant bulbs in the fall. No. 1 M: I planted 10 tulip bulbs in my garden last fall, but some of them didn't come up.

  • Kenta, you plant bulbs in the fall.
  • No.
  • 1 M: I planted 10 tulip bulbs in my garden last fall, but some of them didn't come up.
  • F: Well, the ones that did are beautiful anyway.
  • ) M: Thank you.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
Kenta, you plant bulbs in the fall.

No. 1

M: I planted 10 tulip bulbs in my garden last fall, but some of them didn't come up.

F: Well, the ones that did are beautiful anyway. (Or, Well, the garden is beautiful anyway.)

M: Thank you. I hope we will be able to enjoy more tulips next spring.

No. 2

M: We're going to have some friends over for a p
0
Thank you very much.

Well, the ones that did are beautiful anyway.

You left out "but". If I say "Well, but the ones that .... anyway," is it wrong or odd?
0
I would say either "But the ones that did..." or "Well the ones that did" but not BOTH "Well, but..."

On the other hand, I suppose I may say it in conversation, but it's redundant, and wouldn't do it if iI were writing dialogue.
0
Your explanation is very instructive. Thank you again!

Related Questions