0
Gori Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

Correct interpretation using adjective clause

I sometimes wonder which of the following ( a) or b) ) should be the correct interpretation for the example below:

Example: The figure illustrating the example of A.

a) The figure which illustrates the example of A.
b) The figure which is illustrating the example of A.

This is just one example using the "ing" form in an adjective clause, but I would like to know whether the answer must be always either the case a) or b), or whether both are considered to be correct.
  

Top answer

The figure illustrating the example of A is correct. To me, (a) The figure which illustrates the example of A is also correct. To me, (b) The figure which is illustrating the example of A is incorrect.

  • The figure illustrating the example of A is correct.
  • To me, (a) The figure which illustrates the example of A is also correct.
  • To me, (b) The figure which is illustrating the example of A is incorrect.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
The figure illustrating the example of A is correct.

To me, (a) The figure which illustrates the example of A
is also correct.

To me, (b) The figure which is illustrating the example of A is incorrect.
0
"The figure illustrating the example of A." OK

a)" The figure which illustrates the example of A." OK
b) "The figure which is illustrating the example of A." OK

a or b depends on the situation

These are not grammatical sentences, mind.

Related Questions