0
Anonymous Posted 15 years ago
Grammar
Coodination
Hello, I'm studying English. Today I want to ask native speakers if the following sentences are grammatical.
The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category. Then, what about the coodination of a gerund and a noun phrase? I would be appreciated if you native speakers tell me your intuition.
a. Bill's coming and Mary's leaving bothers me.
b. Bill's arriving and Mary's departure bothers me.
c. Bill's arrival and Mary's leaving bothers me.
The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category. Then, what about the coodination of a gerund and a noun phrase? I would be appreciated if you native speakers tell me your intuition.
a. Bill's coming and Mary's leaving bothers me.
b. Bill's arriving and Mary's departure bothers me.
c. Bill's arrival and Mary's leaving bothers me.
Top answer
Hi, I'm studying English. Today I want to ask native speakers if the following sentences are grammatical. The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category.
- Hi, I'm studying English.
- Today I want to ask native speakers if the following sentences are grammatical.
- The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category.
- This is a strong statement by your grammar book.
- I would say simply that the use of 'the same category' results in much better style.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
2 Answers
0
Hi,
I'm studying English. Today I want to ask native speakers if the following sentences are grammatical.
The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category. This is a strong statement by your grammar book. I would say simply that the use of '
I'm studying English. Today I want to ask native speakers if the following sentences are grammatical.
The grammar book says that the coordination structure will be allowed only when the two elements belong to the same category. This is a strong statement by your grammar book. I would say simply that the use of '
00
Thank you for your kind and quick reply! I'm really glad to know your intuition and your opinion about the coordination structure. From the above facts, I totally agree with what you said. Thank you:)
0
Related Questions