0
Anonymous Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Confused regarding Conditionals

I would not have talked to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.

I would not be talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.

I would not have talked to you if I did not feel compelled to do so.

I would not have been talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.

If anybody could explain the sense of the above sentences and how are they different to each other; and tell whether if these are grammatically correct, I would be gratified.
  

Top answer

Anonymous I would not have talked to you if I had not felt compelled to do so. [ if I didn't feel compelled ] I would not have been talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so. [correct] If anybody could explain the sense of the above sentences and how are they different to each other; and tell whether if these are grammatically correct, I would be gratified.

  • Anonymous I would not have talked to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.
  • [ if I didn't feel compelled ] I would not have been talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.
  • [correct] If anybody could explain the sense of the above sentences and how are they different to each other; and tell whether if these are grammatically correct, I would be gratified.
  • First: correct, both actions in the past Second: present Third: correct, both actions in the past
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
AnonymousI would not have talked to you if I had not felt compelled to do so. [correct]

I would not be talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so.I would not have talked to you if I did not feel compelled to do so.[if I didn't feel compelled]

I would not have been talking to you if I had not felt compelled to do so. [correct]

I
0
thanks a lot. Would you please explain whether there is any difference between the first and the third, and if there is any, what is that?

Related Questions