0
Anonymous Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

Conditional clauses' meaning

For example "if I were you, I would've done it" means "I'm not you, so I didn't do it". Does it have some sort of regulations or is it alright as long as it has the same meaning?
  

Top answer

Anonymous "if I were you, I would've done it" means "I'm not you, so I didn't do it". No, it doesn't mean that. It doesn't mean I didn't do it (even though I didn't because I wasn't even in the same situation that I'm imagining).

  • Anonymous "if I were you, I would've done it" means "I'm not you, so I didn't do it".
  • No, it doesn't mean that.
  • It doesn't mean I didn't do it (even though I didn't because I wasn't even in the same situation that I'm imagining).
  • It means you didn't do it, but if I had been in your place in the same situation that you were in, I would have acted differently than you did and would have done it.
  • Anonymous Does it have some sort of regulations I'm not sure what kind of regulations you are talking about.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

3 Answers
0
Anonymous"if I were you, I would've done it" means "I'm not you, so I didn't do it".
No, it doesn't mean that. It doesn't mean I didn't do it (even though I didn't because I wasn't even in the same situation that I'm imagining). It means you didn't do it, but if I had been in your place in the same situation that you were in, I wo
0
CalifJim It means you didn't do it, but if I had been in your place in the same situation that you were in, I would have acted differently than you did and would have done it.
I agree that this is the most likely interpretation, but there is another:

A: I'm an idiot. I divorced her. Just because she was unfaithful once, I divorced her. She was so b
0
fivejedjonbut there is another
Aha! So I see.

CJ

Related Questions