0
Anonymous Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Commas around the phrase?

Hi. Do we have to put the commas around the phrase "with him" (it was placed there for emphasis) in the following example sentence?

He saw him and, with him, he started a conversation.

How about this? Should there be commas around the phrase "with him," too? Thank you in advance for your help.

He saw him and, with him, started a conversation.

  

Top answer

Do we have to put the commas around the phrase "with him" (it was placed there for emphasis) in the following example sentence? He saw him and, with him, he started a conversation. With or without commas, I wouldn't say it is incorrect, but both versions are odd and unnatural.

  • Do we have to put the commas around the phrase "with him" (it was placed there for emphasis) in the following example sentence?
  • He saw him and, with him, he started a conversation.
  • With or without commas, I wouldn't say it is incorrect, but both versions are odd and unnatural.
  • Natural English is eg He saw him and started a conversation with him.
  • eg He saw him and started a conversation.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

. Do we have to put the commas around the phrase "with him" (it was placed there for emphasis) in the following example sentence?

He saw him and, with him, he started a conversation. With or without commas, I wouldn't say it is incorrect, but both versions are odd and unnatural.

Natural English is

eg He saw him and started a conversation with him.

Related Questions