0
Snarf Posted 13 years ago
Grammar

Comma Query Regarding a Long, Descriptive Sentence

He grabs at the rocks, crushing them, while laughing to himself joyously, in the fiery sunshine beating down on his neck, light years away from home.

How is that comma after "joyously"? Does it make it too choppy?

Thanks.
  

Top answer

Snarf How is that comma after "joyously"? Does it make it too choppy? Far too many commas, and it is too choppy anyway.

  • Snarf How is that comma after "joyously"?
  • Does it make it too choppy?
  • Far too many commas, and it is too choppy anyway.
  • Recast a bit: He grabs at the rocks, crushing them , and laughs to himself joy ously in the fiery sunshine beating down on his n eck light years away from home.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

13 Answers
0
SnarfHow is that comma after "joyously"? Does it make it too choppy?
Far too many commas, and it is too choppy anyway. Recast a bit:

He grabs at the rocks, crushing them, and laughs to himself joyously in the fiery sunshine beating down on his neck light years away from home.
0
You wouldn't put a comma between neck and light?!
0
SnarfYou wouldn't put a comma between neck and light?!
I certainly would not! 'Light years away from home' is restrictive.
0
So there's no pause after neck, given "light years away from home" is additional information?
0
Interesting. So a sentence like this, I guess, definitely doesn't need a comma, then:

He ran as fast as he could deeper and deeper into the cave.
0
SnarfSo a sentence like this, I guess, definitely doesn't need a comma, then:He ran as fast as he could deeper and deeper into the cave.
No, none is necessary at all.
0
Okay. Speaking of commas, as I often do...

She walks in wearing a short tight dress.

I used to think an adjectival comma is necessary there after "short," but then I started thinking otherwise, and now I'm confused. In this case, it's probably just a matter of taste, right? In terms of the "and" test, a comma does not belong, since it doesn't s
0
Snarfit's probably just a matter of taste, right? In terms of the "and" test, a comma does not belong,
I agree.
Snarfit doesn't sound natural, at least not to me, to say, "...short and tight dress.
I agree.
0
I would not write this sentence in this manner. My best rewrite effort:

As he grabs the rocks, crushing them while laughing to himself joyously, he feels the sun's burning heat, coming from light years away, penetrate the skin on the back of his neck.

I personally don't like my rewrite, but I tried to stay as true to the original as possible.

Related Questions