0
Flora123 Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Comma between two verbs having the same subject

I am referring to the rule "Do not put a comma between two verbs that have a common subject."

So the following sentences in some fictional works are fine to me:
"The other man spoke to him sharply and pointed to the camel drivers..."
"She lay down again and faced the sky above her, seeing the high palms..."

But the other sentences, written by acclaimed writers (even for those same books), seem going another way:

A. Two verbs in a compound predicate (with a coordinating conjunction like "and" between them)

1. Kit stood unmoving, and slowly looked about the bare little room with the door on one side, and a window on the other.
3. She wept, and let a few tears fall on him.
4. She had become quite docile, and ate whatever was fed her, but the men took no chances.
5. Port was silent awhile, and said in a whisper: “That, for instance.”

B. No coordinating conjunction between two verbs
1. They came to a village, went through it.
2. Through the open door, she'd seen the lights shining, hearded the droning of prayers.
3. She looked into the sky, saw space growing ever clearer.
6. She fumbled in her handbag for the slip of paper Mr. Clarke had given her, found it.
7. We walked back, found a ladder in the garage.
8. We got out of the pool, showered.

I think the sentence had better break into two independent clauses connected by a coordinating conjunction, so the comma can be placed before the conjunction, e.g., A4 "She had become quite docile, and she ate whatever was fed her, but the men took no chances."
But this way seems not good for dramatic effect in fiction with other sentences.

Please help let me know:
- Is it okay to break that rule in writing fiction?
- Can we accept those sentences using other rules ("Use commas to set off words that add emphasis, shift attention, provide a fuller explanation, separate contrasted elements or to indicate a distinct pause")?
- Your further advice for this case.

Many thanks.
  

Top answer

flora123 - Is it okay to break that rule in writing fiction? Yes. For example, here is the context of B3.

  • flora123 - Is it okay to break that rule in writing fiction?
  • Yes.
  • For example, here is the context of B3.
  • Her eyes were already open.
  • Dawn was breaking.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
flora123- Is it okay to break that rule in writing fiction?
Yes. For example, here is the context of B3.

Her eyes were already open. Dawn was breaking. The rock she leaned against hurt her back. She sighed, and shifted her position a bit. Among the rocks out there beyond the town it was very quiet at t
0
Thank you very much. Your reply is very helpful to me. I like this: "It sets the mood for the reader."
(You quickly identified the context, text of P. Bowles; I'm impressed.)
0
flora123I am referring to the rule "Do not put a comma between two verbs that have a common subject."
This is not so much a rule as advice give by some writers of style guides. It is often ignored, in BrE at least.
flora1231. Kit stood unmoving, and slowly
0
Thank you for your helpful comments, in particular those on group A sentences. I get a better picture of applying this comma rule now.

Related Questions