0
HeloOO Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

Combine sentence with 'and'

Hi,

I have questions about combining sentences using 'and' without changing the original meaning.

Suppose I have 2 sentences:
1. Data has been updated in system X.
2. Data has been updated in system Y.

Are these correct ?

a. Data has been updated in system X and Y. (sounds like X and Y is one system)

b. Data has been updated in system X and system Y.
b. Data has been updated in system X and in system Y.(sounds long winded)

How about this?
1. I bought a new bag.
2. I bought a new shirt.
3. I bought a new cap.

Are these correct?

a. I bought a new bag, shirt and cap.
b. I bought a new bag, new shirt and new cap.

b. I bought a new bag, a new shirt and a new cap.

I tried searching 'combine and' but there are too many results. If you know the relevant search term for this kind of question please tell me Emotion: smile
  

Top answer

Hi, i assume that in your first question you are correct in these ones b. Data has been updated in system X and system Y. b.

  • Hi, i assume that in your first question you are correct in these ones b.
  • Data has been updated in system X and system Y.
  • b.
  • Data has been updated in system X and in system Y.
  • but you can write like this too: Data has been updated in X and Y systems.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Hi,

i assume that in your first question you are correct in these ones

b. Data has been updated in system X and system Y.

b. Data has been updated in system X and in system Y.

but you can write like this too:

Data has been updated in X and Y systems.



and in your second question you don't have to write new for each one so it is better
0
I'd put a determiner before "Data" in any case.

All data in systems X and Y has been updated.
The pertinent data in systems X and Y has been updated.

I agree that a, b and b are all equally correct, but I'd say a.

Related Questions