0
Deborahjeong Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Clarification

She sobbed, having scolded her children. Does the sentence mean "she sobbed after she scolded her children" or "she sobbed and then she scolded her children"? Could anyone help me clarify the meaning?

  

Top answer

The relationship between a participle clause and its associated sentence is not explicitly expressed, so it's often a matter of guesswork. after she scolded her children is possible. So is because she scolded her children .

  • The relationship between a participle clause and its associated sentence is not explicitly expressed, so it's often a matter of guesswork.
  • after she scolded her children is possible.
  • So is because she scolded her children .
  • Absent any further context, I'm inclined to interpret it as a because relationship.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

The relationship between a participle clause and its associated sentence is not explicitly expressed, so it's often a matter of guesswork.

after she scolded her children is possible. So is because she scolded her children.

Absent any further context, I'm inclined to interpret it as a because relationship.

CJ

Related Questions