0
Catttt Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Celebrating rather than exposing them

1. Does the green sentence mean "the soldiers whom I was painting probably thought I was painting their victory rather than their atrocities"?


2. Does the orange sentence mean "They would have said 'It shows our boys vertical and the gooks down. That’s a victory painting. Just like the Romans and the Greeks showed off their victories, the winners and the losers' "?



Context:

The well-trained and highly regarded Leon Golub observed:
And the guys I portray, one could say I was celebrating rather than exposing them. For example, if the Pentagon had wanted, they could have displayed one of [my] huge Vietnam paintings and claimed it as a victory painting. It shows our boys vertical and the gooks down. That’s a victory painting. Just like the Romans and the Greeks showed off their victories, the winners and the losers. So why is this an anti-war painting?

  

Top answer

1. No. "One" refers to "someone/anyone" or "people in general", not to a person portrayed.

  • 1.
  • No.
  • "One" refers to "someone/anyone" or "people in general", not to a person portrayed.
  • The sentence means "One could say (that) I was celebrating rather than exposing the guys (that) I portray".
  • The object, "the guys I portray", has been brought to the front for emphasis or other stylistic reasons, or perhaps just because it came into the speaker's mind first.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0

1. No. "One" refers to "someone/anyone" or "people in general", not to a person portrayed. The sentence means "One could say (that) I was celebrating rather than exposing the guys (that) I portray". The object, "the guys I portray", has been brought to the front for emphasis or other stylistic reasons, or perhaps just because it came into the speaker's mind first.

2. As it is written, th

Related Questions