0
Yaasaay Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Can some expalin this sentence






hi guys

can someine explain this

Mahalia Jackson, ___ combined powerful vitality with great dignity, was one of the best-known gospel singers in the United States.

A.which songs
B.it was her singing
C.whose singing
D.who sang


the correct answer is c

but why I think is d not c
  

Top answer

I agree that C is the correct answer. D would work if you changed the sentence Mahalia Jackson, who sang songs that combined powerful vitality with great dignity, was one of the best known gospel singers in the US. However, even that sentence isn't exactly right because we usually associate vitality and dignity with the way someone sings, not with the songs themselves.

  • I agree that C is the correct answer.
  • D would work if you changed the sentence Mahalia Jackson, who sang songs that combined powerful vitality with great dignity, was one of the best known gospel singers in the US.
  • However, even that sentence isn't exactly right because we usually associate vitality and dignity with the way someone sings, not with the songs themselves.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

4 Answers
0
I agree that C is the correct answer. D would work if you changed the sentence

Mahalia Jackson, who sang songs that combined powerful vitality with great dignity, was one of the best known gospel singers in the US.

However, even that sentence isn't exactly right because we usually associate vitality and dignity with the way someone sings, not with the songs themselv
0
yaasaayBut why do I think it's d and not c?
D would be

Mahalia Jackson, who sang combined powerful vitality with great dignity, was ...

That's putting two pa
0
I understood what you said

but

I didn't understand

why did we choose " whose " rather "who?

what is "whose" refer for?

I know we use "whose" for plural>>>> people
0
"Who" is a relative pronoun and is normally followed by a verb.

I know a man who sings beautifully. ("sings" is a verb)

"Whose" is a determiner and cannot be normally followed by a verb (it has to be a noun)

I know a man whose singing is beautiful. ("singing" is a noun)

Related Questions