0
Usenet Posted 21 years ago
Screenwriting

Bush Signs Tech Censorship Bill

Source: AP
Bush Signs Bill to Let Parents Strip DVDs
Wed Apr 27,11:21 AM ET
WASHINGTON - President Bush on Wednesday signed legislation aimed at helping parents keep their children from seeing sex scenes, violence and foul language in movie DVDs.
The bill gives legal protections to the fledgling filtering technology that helps parents automatically skip or mute sections of commercial movie DVDs. Bush signed it privately and without comment, White House press secretary Scott McClellan said.
The legislation came about because Hollywood studios and directors had sued to stop the manufacture and distribution of such electronic devices for DVD players. The movies' creators had argued that changing the content ? even when it is considered offensive ? would violate their copyrights.
The legislation, called the Family Entertainment and Copyright Act, creates an exemption in copyright laws to make sure companies selling filtering technology won't get sued out of existence.

Critics of the bill have argued it was aimed at helping one company, Utah-based ClearPlay Inc., whose technology is used in some DVD players. ClearPlay sells filters for hundreds of movies that can be added to such DVD players for $4.95 each month. Hollywood executives maintain that ClearPlay should pay them licensing fees for altering their creative efforts.
Unlike ClearPlay, some other companies produce edited DVD copies of popular movies and sell them directly to consumers.

In a nod to the studios, the legislation contains crackdowns on copyright infringement by explicitly providing no legal protections for those companies that sell copies of the edited movies, creating new penalties for criminals who use small videocameras to record copies of first-run films in movie theaters, and setting tough penalties for anyone caught distributing a movie or song prior to its commercial release.
The legislation also reauthorizes a Library of Congress program dedicated to saving rare, culturally significant works, such as home movies, silent-era films and other works that are unlikely to be protected by the big studios.

"Writing is an occupation in which you have to
keep proving your talent to those who have none."
Jules Renard
  

Top answer

I don't get how this device is a bad thing. Isn't it the equivalent of fast-forwarding through "objectionable" scenes? People would use it in the privacy of their own homes; they're not altering copyrighted material for resale.

  • I don't get how this device is a bad thing.
  • Isn't it the equivalent of fast-forwarding through "objectionable" scenes?
  • People would use it in the privacy of their own homes; they're not altering copyrighted material for resale.
  • Lois
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

53 Answers
0
I don't get how this device is a bad thing. Isn't it the equivalent of fast-forwarding through "objectionable" scenes? People would use it in the privacy of their own homes; they're not altering copyrighted material for resale.
Lois
0
[nq:1]I don't get how this device is a bad thing. Isn't it the equivalent of fast-forwarding through "objectionable" scenes? People would use it in the privacy of their own homes; they're not altering copyrighted material for resale.[/nq]
It's a bad thing because at least when one person fast forwards they're doing it for themselves, whereas this bill allows one organization's interpretation o
0
[nq:1]Bush Signs Bill to Let Parents Strip DVDs Wed Apr 27,11:21 AM ET WASHINGTON - President Bush on Wednesday signed ... mute sections of commercial movie DVDs. Bush signed it privately and without comment, White House press secretary Scott McClellan said.[/nq]
- - - snip - - -
Perhaps I don't really understand how this filtering technology works, but how might it affect playback of a fi
0
[nq:1]Perhaps I don't really understand how this filtering technology works, but how might it affect playback of a film like, say, "Farenheit 911"? I'm guessing there wouldn't be very much continuity left in it. W. probably wouldn't like that very much![/nq]
I got to see something similar to this in action, and since I'm... uh... since I'm... SENILE!, I'll just repost it. (The major dif
0
[nq:1]I don't get how this device is a bad thing. Isn't it the equivalent of fast-forwarding through "objectionable" scenes? People would use it in the privacy of their own homes; they're not altering copyrighted material for resale.[/nq]
Lois! What do you think these people are doing?! They're altering copyrighted material and reselling it! If folks out there don't want to watch films with ma
0
H.R.357
Family Entertainment and Copyright Act of 2005 (Introduced in House)

TITLE II EXEMPTION FROM INFRINGEMENT FOR SKIPPING AUDIO AND VIDEO CONTENT IN MOTION PICTURES
SEC. 201. SHORT TITLE.
This title may be cited as the `Family Movie Act of 2005'.

SEC. 202. EXEMPTION FROM INFRINGEMENT FOR SKIPPING AUDIO AND VIDEO CONTENT IN MOTION PICTURES.
(a) In General- Sec
0
Sure makes me suspicious. Anything President George W. Bush touches turns to ***.
0
[nq:2]Perhaps I don't really understand how this filtering technology works, ... left in it. W. probably wouldn't like that very much![/nq]
[nq:1]I got to see something similar to this in action, and since I'm... uh... since I'm... SENILE!, I'll just repost ... If I'm not mistaken these guys did get legally run out of business. (And probably returned with this new technology.)[/nq]
0
Wait a minute I just read this again:
[nq:1]The bill gives legal protections to the fledgling filteringtechnology that helps parents (emphasis mine) automatically skip or mutesections of commercial movie DVDs.[/nq]
Note:
[nq:1]In a nod to the studios, the legislation contains crackdowns on copyright infringement by explicitly providing no legal protectionsfor those companies
0
[nq:1]You guys have it wrong. This IS a device for home use, and does not allow independent companies to sell edited versions of copyrighted material.[/nq]
I suspect the Christianists would be horrified if I published a bowdlerized Bible with stuff like, "The wages of sin is a slap on the wrist," or depicted sinners cast into a lake of sparkly cool water instead of flaming brimstone.
There

Related Questions