0
Usenet Posted 21 years ago
Usage

"breeding out"

Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events.
The state government reacted by enacting legislation to ban the sale, exchange, distribution, importation and husbandry etc of Amercian Pit Bulls, Japanese Tosers (sp?), Argentine Fighting Dogs and a range of others declared to be "dangerous dogs". People in possession of such dogs were required to have them desexed.
The spokesman for the government said that they intended to "breed them out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out?
cheers
Chrissy
  

Top answer

[nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events. them out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate?

  • [nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events.
  • them out of existence".
  • The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate?
  • [/nq] You can take their genes out of the Aussie gene pool by making all members of that breed incapable of reproducing.
  • There's yappy dingoes running around killing kids and yet they are worried to death over some fellow's pet pit bull.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

97 Answers
0
[nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events. ... them out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out?[/nq]
You can take their genes out of the Aussie gene pool by making all members of that breed incapable of reproducing. There's yappy dingoes running around k
0
[nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events. ... of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out? cheers Chrissy[/nq]
There are no bad dogs just bad owners. "Pit Bulls" a breed invented by the press is a catch all term for dogs with blunt muzzles , most are usually
0
[nq:2]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we ... thissemantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out? cheers Chrissy[/nq]
[nq:1]There are no bad dogs just bad owners. "Pit Bulls" a breed inventedby the press is a catch all term ... them to be viscious thinking that that in turn makes them tough. Anydog in the wrong hands can be dangerous.[/nq]
True, but if badly owned dog es
0
[nq:2]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we ... thissemantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out? cheers Chrissy[/nq]
[nq:1]There are no bad dogs just bad owners. "Pit Bulls" a breed inventedby the press is a catch all term ... them to be viscious thinking that that in turn makes them tough. Anydog in the wrong hands can be dangerous.[/nq]
MWCD11 dates "pit bull" to 1950
0
[nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another ofthose "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events. The ... out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is thissemantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out? cheers Chrissy[/nq]
What breeders do is breed a characteristic in or out. It would be rare to breed out a gene, because first you would have to have ident
0
[nq:1]Recently in the state of NSW, here in Australia we had another of those "Amercian pit bull mauls child" events. ... them out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out?[/nq]
Literally no, of course.
But it is possible to breed a particular phrase on a gene out.

And that is routinely done in breeding for improveme
0
[nq:1]And that is routinely done in breeding for improvement. For example, the first siamese cats in the West tended to have kinked tails. This was considered an error, and kinked tails are rarely seem nowadays.[/nq]
That's sad news! We used to have Siamese, and the proper kinked tail was one of their lovable features, like the growl. I never know where I stand with breed societies: they do pr
0
[nq:1]There are no bad dogs just bad owners.[/nq]
People say that about dogs fouling footpaths. But it's definitely the dogs - I've seen them do it.

Phil C.
0
[nq:1]The state government reacted by enacting legislation to ban the sale, exchange, distribution, importation and husbandry etc of Amercian Pit ... them out of existence". The aim is clearly eugenic, but is this semantically accurate? Can one breed some gene out?[/nq]
Yes but:

1. The spokesman did not say these Australians soughtto eliminate the violence gene; he said the aim was by
0
[nq:2]There are no bad dogs just bad owners.[/nq]
[nq:1]People say that about dogs fouling footpaths. But it's definitely the dogs - I've seen them do it. Phil C.[/nq]
In the U.S.A. we have pooper scooper laws, it solves that problem quite nicely.

Related Questions