0
HMFindlay Posted 20 years ago
Grammar

BrE: Re-writing

0When I learn English for Science and Technology at a tuition centre the tutor tends to mix BrE, MyE and AmE altogether and I always rewrite them back as BrE. The Q is, is it acceptable to rewrite proper nouns written in AmE as in Pearl Habor into Pearl Habour and Lindsay Lohan's song Rumor into Rumour? Answer from BrE writers are most welcomed 050010id1
  

Top answer

0 Not really as then you are changing their names. Proper noun spellings should not be messed about with. 0-

  • 0 Not really as then you are changing their names.
  • Proper noun spellings should not be messed about with.
  • 0-
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
0 Not really as then you are changing their names. Proper noun spellings should not be messed about with. 0-
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10HMFindlay12cite10When I learn English for Science and Technology at a tuition centre the tutor tends to mix BrE, MyE and AmE altogether and I always rewrite them back as BrE. The Q is, is it acceptable to rewrite proper nouns written in AmE as in Pearl Habor into Pearl Habour and Lindsay Lohan's song Rumor into Rumour? Answer fro
0
0So are you saying that it's ok to mess with proper nouns from other language but not AmE?02br
02br
00So we can freely change Torino into Turin and Roma into Rome as well as Mallorca into Majorca and Sevilla into Seville, Ciudad de Mexico into Mexico City but we can NEVER mess around with the Yankee English proper nouns including places in the US which are named in Spanish su
0
0Is anyone going to help me on this? Clive? MrPedantic? 05000 Anybody?010id7
0
0Hi,02br
02br
00I don't really have a comprehensive statement for you of how names have come about. Obviously, a lot of it is historical convention and accident, and for sure there is a certain element of cultural arrogance and imperialism involved. I do think that names are more fixed now, harder to change. We live in an age of records and writing, and in a 'global village'
0
0Ooooops!02br
02br
00I meant proper names [should 01font00not02font00be changed], I left out the [not]! Sorry!050010id10
0
0 01blockquote
01cite10Nona The Brit12cite10Not really as then you are changing their names. Proper noun spellings should not be messed about with.12blockquote
10But I was watching National Geographic and the title was : 60th Anniversary of Pearl Harbour 01a
0
0Hi,02br
02br
00The person who wrote the title for National Geographic probably thought the word in the name was spelled with a 'u'.02br
02br
00You can write names in any way you please, there is no law against it. If you want to refer to Buenos Aires as Good Airs, that's fine by me, although the post office may possibly be unsure about where to deliver yo

Related Questions