0
Andyw12345 Posted 18 years ago
Grammar

Being vs. Been

Please could somebody tell me whether the below use of being is correct:

Despite the studies reviewed in Section 2.2 being far from persuasive

Cheers guys!



Emotion: smile
  

Top answer

It's correct. "Despite" is usually applied to a noun, so in this sentence the noun-like "being" serves as the target for "despite". 1.

  • It's correct.
  • "Despite" is usually applied to a noun, so in this sentence the noun-like "being" serves as the target for "despite".
  • 1.
  • Despite the bad weather...
  • 2.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

15 Answers
0
It's correct.

"Despite" is usually applied to a noun, so in this sentence the noun-like "being" serves as the target for "despite".

1. Despite the bad weather...
2. Despite the weather being bad... (which sounds poor but is still correct)
0
Thanks very much for your help!

Much appreciated!
0
To be more correct, the target is the whole noun-like phrase: "studies being far from persuasive".

"Being" makes it noun-like and verb-less.
0
It seems to me that there is an omission of "which are". "Studies which are far from persuasive" turns into "Studies being far from persuasive"
0
Doll:

But your approach won't work with: "Between you and me, I don't like her being here"...
0
Yes, it is something different. Emotion: smile But this is not a full sentence.
0
«Yes, it is something different.»

But using the noun-phrase approach, it's the same thing!

«But this is not a full sentence.»

Why not?
Subject: I
Verb: don't like
Object: her being here
0
Ant_222«Yes, it is something different.» But using the noun-phrase approach, it's the same thing! No. I mean my example , omitting which are, and your explanation is different situations.

«But this is not a full sentence.» Why not? Subject: I Verb: don't like Object: her being here I mean the very first senten
0
«No. I mean my example , omitting which are, and your explanation is different situations. »

I think mine works in both the situations.

Let's better ask Andy: "Have our replies been of help to you?"
0
Yes, your explanation does work. Morover, I don't remeber saying that your explanation doesn't work.

Related Questions