0
Deepcosmos Posted 4 years ago
Grammar

‘be told’ and ‘hear’

Hello, everyone,

“About 80 students were invited to participate in an experiment and were told they would be given some money after a series of tests. A researcher was hired and made the students dislike him by being rude to them. The students took the tests and were all awarded the promised money. They were then divided into three groups. . . . “

* source; from our local textbook

While I understand ‘be told’ and ‘hear’ are frequently interchangeable in many contexts, but in this one above I feel the replacement with ‘heard’ would be a little awkward, since ‘were told’ implies ‘a direct conversation between you and someone’ and ‘heard’ does ‘an indirect becoming to know something, like you saw it on TV, or read it in the newspaper, etc.’

I would appreciate it, if I have your valuable opinions on this matter.

  

Top answer

’ I'd say you understand it, except "heard" would be wrong for the reason you state, not just a little awkward. If you want my advice, though, I wouldn't go looking for the interchangeable. Very, very few things are.

  • ’ I'd say you understand it, except "heard" would be wrong for the reason you state, not just a little awkward.
  • If you want my advice, though, I wouldn't go looking for the interchangeable.
  • Very, very few things are.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
deepcosmosWhile I understand ‘be told’ and ‘hear’ are frequently interchangeable in many contexts, but in this one above I feel the replacement with ‘heard’ would be a little awkward, since ‘were told’ implies ‘a direct conversation between you and someone’ and ‘heard’ does ‘an indirect becoming to know something, like you saw it on TV, or read it in the newspaper, etc.’
0

Hi, deepcosmos,

deepcosmosWhile I understand ‘be told’ and ‘hear’ are frequently interchangeable in many contexts, but in this one above I feel the replacement with ‘heard’ would be a little awkward, since ‘were told’ implies ‘a direct conversation between you and someone’ and ‘heard’ does ‘an indirect becoming to know something, like you saw it on TV, or read it in

Related Questions