0
Taka Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

Be to

I've seen someone say "how to do/what to do/where to do…etc" are ellipsises of "how X is to do/what X is to do/where X is to do…"

Would you native speakers agree? Do "how to do" and "how we are to do" sound exactly the same to your native ear? Do you think the meaning is exactly the same?
  

Top answer

I cannot analyze your problem because you have not put the phrases into representative sentences.

  • I cannot analyze your problem because you have not put the phrases into representative sentences.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
I cannot analyze your problem because you have not put the phrases into representative sentences.
0
There are no representative sentences simply because that person has made such a general statement as above without any examples; he seems to be saying that in general "how to do/what to do…" are equal to "how X to do/what X is to do..."

Well, if you want examples, what about these simple ones?

·He knows how to do it.
·He knows how he is to do it.

To m
0
Taka·He knows how to do it.·He knows how he is to do it.To me, they don't seem the same at all.
Nor to me. Is that all there is to your question, then?
0
I just wondered if that generalization was really valid or not.

And that person has also made this formula: "prep+relative pronoun+to do=prep+relative pronoun+ X is to do"

I wonder if these two are really the same:

I need something with which to write.
I need something with which I am to write.
0
TakaI wonder if these two are really the same:I need something with which to write.I need something with which I am to write.
I can't see how, since it can also mean 'with which she/he/my student/etc is to write'. But if X refers to anyone, then that is a fair paraphrase, I suppose.
0
Mister Micawber . But if X refers to anyone, then that is a fair paraphrase, I suppose.
Would you come up with an example where, like the first how-to-do example, such a conversion wouldn't work? Or do you think his formula generally applies?
0
I don't know about 'conversion'; it is just a paraphrase to me.
0
Then, any example that shows such paraphrasing wouldn't work?
0
So,what's the difference in meaning?
Cuz it seems the same meaning in my languge
He knows how to do it.
He knows how he is to do it.

Related Questions