0
Anonymous Posted 17 years ago
Grammar

BE form

So this is not the first time that I have to argue with my English teacher about my mark. Here is my current problem.
"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather (be) nice."
I was given this sentence with no other context and had to use the right for of "be".
I really am not sure if I was right but I know she is wrong sometimes, even after years of experience. I would like to get some answers as soon as possible because she might rate my work any time. Thank you.
  

Top answer

What answer did you put?

  • What answer did you put?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

7 Answers
0
What answer did you put?
0
I put
"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather is nice."
and my teacher corrected it to
"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather were nice."

I talked to many people about this, some say that only "is" fits, and some say that basically both are correct. To to prove it to my teacher I have to print some very specific grammar rules or else she will just a
0
Anonymous"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather (be) nice."
If I were absolutely required to use the subjunctive, I'd leave it like it is. "If the weather be nice." That's what my grandfather used to say.

I could see using "were" in a present tense situation. "I'd be playing tennis right now if the weather were nice," but I've never
0
Hi,
I'd accept either.

"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather were nice." I might say this in February with 2 metres of snow on the ground. In other words, there is no chance of playing tennis tomorrow. It's a hypothetical, 'unreal' remark.

"I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather is nice." I might say this
0
Hi, and welcome to the forums. I feel your frustration, but try to have patience with your teacher - she's doing the best she can, I"m sure.

You have a "first conditional" in your sentence -- what is said is still possible, and the time refers to the future. You use the present "is."

Look up "first conditional" in Google for a number of sites that will augment your argument.
0
Clive "I would like to play tennis tomorrow if the weather were nice." I might say this in February with 2 metres of snow on the ground. In other words, there is no chance of playing tennis tomorrow. It's a hypothetical, 'unreal' remark.
Hi Clive, I've read this several times, and it finally dawned on me that you might mean "If the weather we
0
Hi,
I was thinking '. . . if the weather were nice tomorrow'.

Clive

Related Questions