0
Marcos Miquelino Posted 8 years ago
Grammar

Auxiliary verbs

I was studying for my next class a question pop up in my mind.

The book says " To ask certain questions, we don't need any auxiliary verb (do, does, did)

and gave as an example, these questions:

What did Mr. Harris say about social networks?;

What makes you happy?; and

Who told you about social networks?


By that it means that I can ask a question like this:


What Mr Harris said about social networks?


From what I've learned, that sound wrong.

  

Top answer

Marcos Miquelino The book says " To ask certain questions, we don't need any auxiliary verb (do, does, did) and gave as an example, these questions: What did Mr. Harris say about social networks? ; It appears that there is a mistake in the book.

  • Marcos Miquelino The book says " To ask certain questions, we don't need any auxiliary verb (do, does, did) and gave as an example, these questions: What did Mr.
  • Harris say about social networks?
  • ; It appears that there is a mistake in the book.
  • You cannot remove 'did' from the underlined question.
  • The other two questions from the book are correct, however.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Marcos MiquelinoThe book says " To ask certain questions, we don't need any auxiliary verb (do, does, did) and gave as an example, these questions: What did Mr. Harris say about social networks?;

It appears that there is a mistake in the book. You cannot remove 'did' from the underlined question.

The other two questions from the book are corre

0

No, your examples are not correct. This is a bit confusing at first to people learning English as a second/foreign language. When the subject of the question is known, the auxiliary will be used -

In this example, we know the subject of the verb:

What did Mr. Harris say about social networks? (Mr. Harris is the subject of "did say."

In the following sentences, we don't know t

Related Questions