0
Qingqing Posted 21 years ago
Grammar

Attributive clause or adverbial clause?

It is the very place where the anti-Japanese soldiers fought over sixty years ago.

It was Sunday when I met with Tom.



Are the underlined parts attributive clause or adverbial clause? Thanks.
  

Top answer

Both where and when can be replaced by that , and they seem to modify the nouns place and Sunday , respectively.

  • Both where and when can be replaced by that , and they seem to modify the nouns place and Sunday , respectively.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

9 Answers
0
Both where and when can be replaced by that, and they seem to modify the nouns place and Sunday, respectively.
0
To me the second sentence seems a kind of cleft sentence.
I met with Tom (on) Sunday
-> It was Sunday when/that I met with Tom

But maybe I am wrong as usual

paco
0
I find "the place where they fought over" odd.

MrP
0
I don't think we can replace where and when with "that", only in this way "It is in the very place that the anti-Japanese soldiers fought over sixty years ago." "It was on Sunday that I met with Tom" can we use "that". Right?
0
Strictly speaking "It was Sunday when I met with Tom" may be grammatically wrong. But many native speakers prefer this to the grammatical cleft sentence. Google will give:
"It was on Sunday that I …" 292
"It was Sunday when I …" 784
I don't think this when clause is an adjective clause. If it is a usual adjective clause the sentence should be like "It was the Sunday when
0
MrPedantic
I find "the place where they fought over" odd.

MrP

I think I misunderstood "over" in the original.

You can say:

1. It is the very place where the anti-Japanese soldiers fought, over sixty years ago.

or

2. It is the very place that the anti-Japanese soldiers fought over, sixty years ago.
0
Adjective clause is always to midify noun . So as long as those two sentences are absolutely modifies noun, (the place/ the day) so they are all adjective clause.

"what is the truth? the truth is sth you make"
so let's make a new truth
0
1font00Hi, I'm Naagii from Mongolia. So I really have to know an adverbial clause. Do you know about it? Please tell me about some site.02font0-
0
0 My thought is that they are atrributive because they relate to the nouns, rather than the verbs. An attribute is something a person or thing possesses. These clauses relate to 'place' and 'Sunday'. 0-

Related Questions