0
Ask Questions Posted 10 years ago
Grammar

Ask?

Hi,

Did you ask your father some money?

Did you ask your father for some money?

Which sentence above is grammatically correct? Should I add "for" preposition to second sentence?
  

Top answer

The first is not correct; the second is.

  • The first is not correct; the second is.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

6 Answers
0
The first is not correct; the second is.
0
Both are grammatical but the second one makes sense.
Ask QuestionsShould I add "for" preposition to second sentence?
In that context, yes.

When you request something form somebody, ask is followed by for. When you ask someone a question, no preposition is used.
Now tell me if money is a question or a kind of request.
0
Persian LearnerBoth are grammatical
The first is not grammatical.
0
fivejedjonThe first is not grammatical.
For all practical purposes I agree with you. However, "Did you ask your father the way to the apartment?", for instance, is grammatical, and "the way to the apartment" and "some money" are both noun phrases. Therefore, one might be able to argue that "Did you ask your father some money?" fails because of a semantic misma
0
It's not to do with 'some money'; it's do do with the difference between ask (speak to to obtain information) and ask for (request).
0
fivejedjonIt's not to do with 'some money'; it's do do with the difference between ask (speak to to obtain information) and ask for (request).
I believe that we interpret it like this because "some money" dominates our understanding of the intended meaning, over the difference between "ask" and "ask for". In a "semantically blind" analysis, in my opinion it is

Related Questions