0
Awence Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Asian 's way of learning tenses.......

Recently, or maybe not just recently, I have come across too many tenses questions set by the Malaysian Chinese Independent School teachers. I totally do not agree with their verb form questions allow only a presumed answer.

Eg:
A few pages have been torn from the book. > What's wrong with a few pages are torn from the book.
(Frankly, I do not see why "are torn" cannot be accepted, there is only a slight difference of meaning. Who says that we can't express the sentence as a piece of fact)

You will have been informed of the programme by tomorrow. (the teacher insists "will have been informed is the only valid answer, i seriously do not see why we can't say

You will be informed of the programme by tomorrow. (The only difference in my opinion is that will have been informed implies the person will obtain the confirmation, most likely, before the advent of tomorrow.

Please give me your opinions on whether my ideas make sense. i seriously do not think questions without a clearer context takes only one valid tense.
  

Top answer

Awence A few pages have been torn from the book. > What's wrong with a few pages are torn from the book. Both are OK.

  • Awence A few pages have been torn from the book.
  • > What's wrong with a few pages are torn from the book.
  • Both are OK.
  • Awence You will have been informed of the programme by tomorrow.
  • (the teacher insists "will have been informed is the only valid answer, i seriously do not see why we can't say You will be informed of the programme by tomorrow.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
AwenceA few pages have been torn from the book. > What's wrong with a few pages are torn from the book.
Both are OK.
AwenceYou will have been informed of the programme by tomorrow. (the teacher insists "will have been informed is the only valid answer, i seriously do not see why we can't say

You will be informed of the pr
0
Many times you may be given many passive structures by your teachers because it is a common mistake among people from Asian countries to underuse and misuse the passive in English. In the actual examples you offered, the passive does sound better, though there are no errors in your suggested sentences. I am guessing you are being given a lot of them for purposes of practice, to accustome you to t

Related Questions