0
Azz Posted 11 years ago
Grammar

As they have been

Can one say
a. I don't want them to fight as they have been in the last few days.
b. I don't want them to fight as they have been doing in the last few days.

c. I don't want them to fight like they have been in the last few days.
d. I don't want them to fight like they have been doing in the last few days.

?


Many thanks.
  

Top answer

My preference is (a) but with a comma after 'fight'. ” This is a wish that they not fight (at all). ” This expands the meaning to say that I wish they not CONTINUE fighting.

  • My preference is (a) but with a comma after 'fight'.
  • ” This is a wish that they not fight (at all).
  • ” This expands the meaning to say that I wish they not CONTINUE fighting.
  • ” This is an attempt to clarify that it’s the ‘doing’ that you don’t want.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
My preference is (a) but with a comma after 'fight'.

“I don’t want them to fight.” This is a wish that they not fight (at all).
“I don’t want them to fight, as they have been (doing).” This expands the meaning to say that I wish they not CONTINUE fighting.
“I don’t want them to fight like they have been…” This might be interpreted to mean ‘I don’t’ like the method of fighting t

Related Questions