0
Jisu98 Posted 19 years ago
Grammar

as soon as/ no sooner~than

From a grammar book, it sounds like 'as soon as', 'no sooner ~than'and 'hardly~when' have similar meanings. Would you check if the belows are the same meanings?

--------------------------------------------------------------

As soon as the gates were open, the crowds rushed in.

The gates had no sooner been open than the crowds rushed in.

The gates had hardly been open when the crowds rushed in.

Martin had no sooner sat down than the phone rang.

Martin had hardly sat down when the phone rang.

As soon as Martin sat down, the phone rang.

Thank you in advance!
  

Top answer

Yes, the meanings are the same, but these are more natural: As soon as the gates were opened , the crowds rushed in. The gates had no sooner been opened than the crowds rushed in. The gates had hardly been opened when the crowds rushed in.

  • Yes, the meanings are the same, but these are more natural: As soon as the gates were opened , the crowds rushed in.
  • The gates had no sooner been opened than the crowds rushed in.
  • The gates had hardly been opened when the crowds rushed in.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
Yes, the meanings are the same, but these are more natural:

As soon as the gates were opened, the crowds rushed in.
The gates had no sooner been opened than the crowds rushed in.
The gates had hardly been opened when

Related Questions