0
Kadioguy Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

As it originally read "Hollywoodland

If I write the sentence below, is it grammatically correct?

As/Because it originally read "Hollywoodland," the Hollywood sign was erected in 1923 at the cost of $21,000 as an advertisement for a real estate development.


From the original sentence:

Hollywood sign, Los Angeles, California

Originally reading "Hollywoodland," the Hollywood sign was erected in 1923 at the cost of $21,000 as an advertisement for a real estate development.
https://www.ahdictionary.com/word/search.html?q=w&submit.x=30&submit.y=16

-----------------

Rover_KE said, "There's no reason to begin with 'As'."

https://www.usingenglish.com/forum/threads/254001-Originally-reading


I replied, "'As' means 'Because' here. Because it originally read 'Hollywoodland', it is a sign relating to 'real estate'".

----------------

What do you think?

PS - I don't know why 'font bold' doesn't take effect.

  

Top answer

kadioguy What do you think? 'As/Because' is the wrong paraphrase. There is no cause-and-effect implied in the original sentence.

  • kadioguy What do you think?
  • 'As/Because' is the wrong paraphrase.
  • There is no cause-and-effect implied in the original sentence.
  • This is its paraphrase: The Hollywood sign originally read 'Hollywoodland', and it was erected in 1923 at the cost of $21,000 as an advertisement for a real estate development.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
kadioguyWhat do you think?

'As/Because' is the wrong paraphrase. There is no cause-and-effect implied in the original sentence. This is its paraphrase:

The Hollywood sign originally read 'Hollywoodland', and it was erected in 1923 at the cost of $21,000 as an advertisement for a real estate development.

Related Questions