Are you now, or have you ever been?

Question

As above, the topic title "Are you now, or have you ever been?" I believe that derived from journlism as I've come across in several news columns. Now, what does it really imply and how do we use it? Does it carry along sarcasm?

Abbie1948 · Accepted Answer

These were the opening lines of cross-examination before the House Un-American Activities Committee in the 1950's. At this time, the US government was terrified of communists, and hundreds of people were investigated by this committee which was headed by Senator Joseph McCarthy.

I suppose it does now carry a hint of sarcasm - well spotted.

Korsav · Answer

Alright, was kinda searching all over the worldwideweb for definitions but to no avail. Now it seems that this phrase is widely or is it loosely used nowadays...say - "Are you now, or have you ever been a journalist/artist/reporter/musician and other mixs". Does it question in intrigue - "Are you only now that you claim to be a detective or were you all along a detective?" Sort of a "wannabe" thing?

Abbie1948 · Answer

Hi Korsav,

I think it's mainly used in a joking sense, simply referring to the inquisitorial approach of the
Un-American Activities Committee. They questioned people for days, and probed into every aspect of their lives. Many famous people in the film industry etc. were questioned, and some even left the US because of it. Some people never worked for years after appearing before this committee, so it was a very serious thing.

It really simply shows that the questioner is asking a personal question - usually related to employment. We would not use it in a formal situation now - only informally, and only as a joke.

Are you now, or have you ever been?

Top answer

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

Related Questions