0
Anonymous Posted 17 years ago
Linguistics Studies

Are we ready to kiss "whom" goodbye?

"Kiss whom goodbye. It is rarely heard in conversation now, and just about never in clause-initial position."
G K Pullum

http://158.130.17.5/%7Emyl/languagelog/archives/001437.html
  

Top answer

Did you have some sort of question about this?

  • Did you have some sort of question about this?
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

18 Answers
0
Did you have some sort of question about this?
0
False. I use it pretty often, for example:

Whom I'd of done such a thing?
Whom est up my room? What a mess!
0
AnonymousKiss whom goodbye. It is rarely heard in conversation now
Certainly it's an unusual collocation. But perhaps:


Middle-aged mother to son, deciding to come clean at last, as "Uncle" Frank prepares to depart:

"Aren't you going to kiss your father goodbye, darling?"

Son:

"Kiss whom
0
I am ready to kiss it goodbye in some situations. I would never say: "Whom did you meet?", but I do use it after prepositions, though I am probably more likely to use the inverted form e.g. "Who by?"

Anyway, I don't think G K Pullum should be laying down the law on the matter. Let those who want to carry on using it do so.
0
Grammar GeekDid you have some sort of question about this?


See the thread title.
0
KooyeenFalse. I use it pretty often, for example:

Whom I'd of done such a thing?
Whom est up my room? What a mess!


You've sense of whomer!
0
ForbesAnyway, I don't think G K Pullum should be laying down the law on the matter. Let those who want to carry on using it do so.

Yeah. They'll become oddities. Why not let 'em go that way if they want to?
0
Anonymous They'll become oddities.
I'm reminded of an episode at another forum.

MrP
0
MrPedantic
Anonymous They'll become oddities.
I'm reminded of an episode at another forum.

MrP
That's great, but what does it have to do with the thread question?
0
AnonymousThat's great, but what does it have to do with the thread question?
Sometimes people are remarkably unaware of how much they themselves use "whom".

MrP

Related Questions