0
Zuotengdazuo Posted 7 years ago
Grammar

Are they the same? If he (had) escaped...

[36] If he had escaped by jumping out of the window he would have left footprints in the flower-bed beneath. And that is precisely what we found.


I begin by presenting the world in which he jumped out of the window as potentially different from the actual world. But it turns out that the consequential property Q obtains in the real world as well as the imaginary one – and the natural explanation for Q is P, so the inference is that P does in fact hold of the actual world. The strategy here, then, is to reconstruct what happened by working back from consequences to their causes.

Hi. This text is from the Cambridge Grammar of the English Language. Example sentence 36 is cited to demonstrate that a remote conditional can express somebody’s confidence that the if-clause is true.

Question: Can we say “If he escaped by jumping out of the window he would have left footprints in the flower-bed beneath. And that is precisely what we found.” to mean the same thing as the original sentence? (That is, to deduce from the main clause, which is proved to be true, that the if-clause is also true)

Thank you.

  

Top answer

zuotengdazuo Question: Can we say “If he escaped by jumping ... Perfectionists might quibble about the choice of tense, but essentially yes, you can say that, and it will be understood that you mean the same thing as if you had said 'had escaped'. CJ

  • zuotengdazuo Question: Can we say “If he escaped by jumping ...
  • Perfectionists might quibble about the choice of tense, but essentially yes, you can say that, and it will be understood that you mean the same thing as if you had said 'had escaped'.
  • CJ
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
zuotengdazuoQuestion: Can we say “If he escaped by jumping ...

Perfectionists might quibble about the choice of tense, but essentially yes, you can say that, and it will be understood that you mean the same

Related Questions