0
Anonymous Posted 15 years ago
Essay & Composition Writing

Appreciate suggestions on this blurb

I'm republishing a booklet from the 1920's and I would be grateful for critical suggestions on the blurb I've drafted. How much of it looks unclear, ungrammatical or just plain silly?


On Some Disputed Points in English Grammar, by Otto Jespersen

This booklet forms part of a classic exchange between two linguistic greats, Otto Jespersen and H. W. Fowler, author of The King's English and A Dictionary of Modern English Usage. Jespersen, Professor of English at Copenhagen University, challenges Fowler on what he characterised as too much “grammatical moralizing” in his usage guides. He takes several constructions criticised in those guides and sets out to justify them, arguing that they have occurred for centuries in the best writers, and that under a deeper analysis they are logically defensible. For example:

- “That long nose of his” (Fowler argued that “of his” means,
literally, “among his noses”); and

- “I insist on them being here” (should be possessive “their”,
according to Fowler).

The discussion gets quite technical in parts, but anyone interested in the
nitty gritty of English usage-and particularly fans and critics of Fowler-
should find the effort worth while.

Originally published by the Society for Pure English in S.P.E. Tract no.
XXV, in 1926.

Thanks,

Sam
  

Top answer

Hi Sam, A few suggestions in blue. Regards, John This booklet forms part of a classic exchange between two linguistic greats, Otto Jespersen and H. W.

  • Hi Sam, A few suggestions in blue.
  • Regards, John This booklet forms part of a classic exchange between two linguistic greats, Otto Jespersen and H.
  • W.
  • Fowler, author of The King's English and A Dictionary of Modern English Usage .
  • Here (below - or you could even start the sentence with 'We see') we see Jespersen, Professor of English at Copenhagen University, challenge Fowler on what he character ises as too much “grammatical moralizing” in his usage guides.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

1 Answers
0
Hi Sam,

A few suggestions in blue.

Regards,

John

This booklet forms part of a classic exchange between two linguistic greats, Otto Jespersen and H. W. Fowler, author of The King's English and A Dictionary of Modern English Usage. Here (below - or you could even start the sentence with 'We see') we see Jespersen,

Related Questions