0
JohnKeats Posted 15 years ago
Grammar

Any + singular or plural?

Which one is correct?

This should not be discussed with any person who was not at the meeting.

This should not be discussed with any persons who were not at the meeting.

Thanks a lot.

JK
  

Top answer

Hi, It should not be discussed with anyone who wasn't present at the meeting. Regards

  • Hi, It should not be discussed with anyone who wasn't present at the meeting.
  • Regards
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

8 Answers
0
Hi,

It should not be discussed with anyone who wasn't present at the meeting.

Regards
0
Thanks, Regards.

Actually, I know that the sentence you proposed is better than mine.

I just wanted your confirmation about the following rule:

any + countable noun = plural

any + uncountable noun = singular

We didn't have any problems (countable) going through customs.
They never give me any help (uncountable).
Please correct any mistakes (coun
0
Hi,

Broadly speaking, you should use any with uncountable nouns or plural nouns when the connotation

being made is negative.

I don't need any help (uncountable).

I don't have any oranges (countable).

We didn't have any problems (countable).

I don't have any money (uncountable).

Your reasoning is correct, then.
0
You asked a specific question and Regards provided you with a good answer.

Concerning your rule, it is correct.

But, taking into consideration your example sentences, the preferred plural of "person" is "people." Persons is acceptable, however, and you second sentence is correct. Yet, I think most people would use "people" and not "persons" these days.

John
0
Hi,

Yes, persons is usually used in formal contexts, and in the vast majority of contexts you

should use person.

Regards
0
Hi John.

I'm not a native but I, too, feel my second sentence is correct. I discussed it on another Forum and a native speaker replied to me that both forms are correct. Now you confirm my feeling. So thanks a lot (to you and Regards). (My example sentences aren't actually mine; I found them on that Forum.)

JK
0
Sorry Paris to bother you again.

This should not be discussed with any person who was not at the meeting.

This should not be discussed with any persons who were not at the meeting.

If the second sentence is correct, what about the first one?

(If the first one, too, is correct, is there any differences between the two sentences?
0
Both sentences are correct and convey the same information.

One is singular, the other plural.

You may say or write either.

John

Related Questions