0
Vsuresh Posted 9 years ago
Grammar

Antecedent

Please help me with this sentence.


An important member of a gang of thieves who had indulged in many cases of housebreaking has been arrested.

I understand that has been arrested agrees with an important member, but I am confused with had indulged as to whether it refers to an important member or the gang of thieves.


  

Top answer

An important member of a gang of thieves who had indulged in many cases of housebreaking has been arrested . The natural interpretation is that who refers to gang of thieves . We understand that a gang of thieves had indulged in many cases of house breaking, and an important member of that gang has been arrested.

  • An important member of a gang of thieves who had indulged in many cases of housebreaking has been arrested .
  • The natural interpretation is that who refers to gang of thieves .
  • We understand that a gang of thieves had indulged in many cases of house breaking, and an important member of that gang has been arrested.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0

An important member of a gang of thieves who had indulged in many cases of housebreaking has been arrested.

The natural interpretation is that who refers to gang of thieves. We understand that a gang of thieves had indulged in many cases of house breaking, and an important member of that gang has been arrested.




0
vsureshhad indulged in

This is weird and unnatural. When discussing crimes, people normally talk of criminals committing them.

Related Questions