0
Anonymous Posted 12 years ago
Grammar

Another sentence that sounds unnatural

It being a holiday season, the train was full.

Is this sentence correct?
  

Top answer

Anonymous Is this sentence correct? Strictly, yes; practically, no. Since it was a holiday, the train was full.

  • Anonymous Is this sentence correct?
  • Strictly, yes; practically, no.
  • Since it was a holiday, the train was full.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

5 Answers
0
AnonymousIs this sentence correct?
Strictly, yes; practically, no.

Since it was a holiday, the train was full.
0
many thanks for the swift response. But I learnt that participle phrase is only used to refer to the same subject in the sentence. For example: walking down the road, I met a nice lady.
0
AnonymousI learnt that participle phrase is only used to refer to the same subject in the sentence.
Only when the participle has no subject of its own, but in your original sentence, it does.
0
Does that mean I can also say: "Sara being my girlfriend, I was happy"?
"Sara" here and "it" in the original sentence play the same function.

Is this sentence also correct?
0
AnonymousDoes that mean I can also say: "Sara being my girlfriend, I was happy"?
Yes indeed, but again natives do not use that structure; we generally eschew 'being' clauses.

I was happy because Sara was my girlfriend.

Related Questions