0
DorisPao Posted 10 years ago
Grammar
Annoying articles
Hi everyone,
Can one of you helpful native English speakers help me with this?
1. Returning an item at the store:
"We can offer you a replacement or a refund."
"Thanks, I think I will go with a/the refund".
I think either is okay. A refund is any refund, 'the' is the one just offered. I don't see how either one is an error in this context.
2.
"If offered an apple or a banana, which would you prefer?"
"A/the banana.
I think "the" is a bit better (it's the banana that's offered), but I think "a banana" wouldn't be wrong either, the implication being that any banana is preferable to an apple.
3. "Would you like a glass of wine or a beer?"
"I'd love a beer."
I think "a beer" is much better, but "the" is not totally incorrect either (the beer offered)
I'd love the opinion of a native English speaker!
Can one of you helpful native English speakers help me with this?
1. Returning an item at the store:
"We can offer you a replacement or a refund."
"Thanks, I think I will go with a/the refund".
I think either is okay. A refund is any refund, 'the' is the one just offered. I don't see how either one is an error in this context.
2.
"If offered an apple or a banana, which would you prefer?"
"A/the banana.
I think "the" is a bit better (it's the banana that's offered), but I think "a banana" wouldn't be wrong either, the implication being that any banana is preferable to an apple.
3. "Would you like a glass of wine or a beer?"
"I'd love a beer."
I think "a beer" is much better, but "the" is not totally incorrect either (the beer offered)
I'd love the opinion of a native English speaker!
Top answer
I think either is okay. A refund is any refund, 'the' is the one just offered. I don't see how either one is an error in this context.
- I think either is okay.
- A refund is any refund, 'the' is the one just offered.
- I don't see how either one is an error in this context.
- I agree.
- I think "the" is a bit better (it's the banana that's offered), but I think "a banana" wouldn't be wrong either, the implication being that any banana is preferable to an apple.
Get the Weekly English Kit 📬
New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.
2 Answers
0
DorisPaoThanks, I think I will go with a/the refund".I think either is okay. A refund is any refund, 'the' is the one just offered. I don't see how either one is an error in this context.I agree.
DorisPao"A/the banana.I think "the" is a bit better (it's the banana that's offered), but I think "a banana" wouldn't be wrong either, the im
00
Related Questions