0
Wangqh2696122 Posted 16 years ago
Grammar

"and" or "but"?

So what makes a scientist? A bright mind is a prerequisite, ____ one also needs a spoonful of good luck.



The given answer is "but", but I think "and" is also ok. What do you think?
  

Top answer

wangqh2696122 What do you think? I think it's "but" because of the implied contrast. Intelligence (a bright mind) is given by nature and can be developed by its possessor, but good luck comes through a more random process whereby the environment contributes (or not) to scientific success.

— CalifJim

  • wangqh2696122 What do you think?
  • I think it's "but" because of the implied contrast.
  • Intelligence (a bright mind) is given by nature and can be developed by its possessor, but good luck comes through a more random process whereby the environment contributes (or not) to scientific success.
  • In the first case, the subject has control of his destiny; in the second case, not.
  • Note also that "but" here acknowledges that only having a bright mind is not enough -- more is needed -- which I believe is the point of the sentence.
Free · every Monday

Get the Weekly English Kit 📬

New words, one handy idiom, and a 2-minute quiz — delivered to your inbox to keep your streak alive.

2 Answers
0
wangqh2696122What do you think?
I think it's "but" because of the implied contrast. Intelligence (a bright mind) is given by nature and can be developed by its possessor, but good luck comes through a more random process whereby the environment contributes (or not) to scientific success. In the first case, the subject has control of his destiny; in th
0
0
Hi,

I agree with what has been said, but I wouldn't go as far as saying 'and' is actually incorrect.

Such tests ask you to choose what seems to fit best, or at least what the examiner thinks fits best. They are not solely about correct and incorrect grammar.
0

Related Questions